期刊信息

  • 刊名: 河北师范大学学报(教育科学版)Journal of Hebei Normal University (Educational Science Edition)
  • 主办: 河北师范大学
  • ISSN: 1009-413X
  • CN: 13-1286/G

  • 教育部名栏入选期刊
  • 全国中文核心期刊
  • CSSCI扩展版来源期刊
  • AMI综合评价(A刊)核心期刊
  • RCCSE中国核心学术期刊
  • 全国高校特色栏目社科学报
  • 中国人民大学“复印报刊资料”重要转载来源期刊
  • 全国高校权威社科期刊

多重制度逻辑下高校教师人事场域的改革变迁

收稿日期: 2021-11-5 PDF 下载 (2)
  • 作者单位: (西南财经大学 a.公共管理学院;b.组织人事部,四川 成都 611130)
  • 起止页码: 96 - 103
  •        DOI: 10.13763/j.cnki.jhebnu.ese.2022.02.013

University Faculty Personnel Field Under MultiInstitutional Logics: Evolution and Reform

摘要/Abstract

摘要:

在多重制度逻辑的理论框架下,通过对我国高校教师人事制度的演进及其当前改革实践进行分析发现,从新中国成立初期的教师任命制,到改革开放后的教师职务聘任制,再到进入21世纪的高校教师岗位聘用制,我国高校教师人事制度场域中的国家逻辑影响逐步减弱,大学管理逻辑稳步增强,市场逻辑悄然渗透,学术逻辑得到重视。在高层次人才引进、岗位分类改革和“准聘-长聘制”改革等高校人事制度改革的三种主要形态中,不同类型的制度逻辑发挥了不同程度的作用。国家和大学在建设世界一流大学的共同目标下相互协作,大力引进高层次人才。同时,国家通过“放管服”改革,提供政策支持和资源保障,鼓励大学自主探索聘任制改革与岗位分类改革。在绩效、竞争等市场理念的影响下,合同聘用、“非升即走”和聘期考核等规则被广泛采用。通过校内各级学术委员会和同行评议制度,学术逻辑持续发挥作用。未来,我国高校须在兼顾竞争与保障、效率与公平等因素的基础上,平衡绩效竞争与教师职业安全,转向以学术逻辑为主导、其他制度逻辑良性竞争的教师人事制度改革。

Abstract:

Under the theoretical framework of multiinstitutional logics, through analyzing the evolution and current reform practices of China’s university personnel system, it is found that from the teacher identity appointment system in the early days of the PRC, to the faculty position appointment system after the reform and opening up, and to the faculty tenure track system in the 21st century, the influence of state logic in China’s university faculty personnel system is gradually weakened, the university management logic is steadily strengthened, the market logic gradually gets in, and the academic logic is given weight. In the three main forms of personnel system reform in universities, i.e., the introduction of highlevel talents, the reform of job classification and the reform of “tenure track system,” different types of institutional logic have played different roles. Under the common goal of building worldclass universities, the state and universities cooperate with each other and vigorously bring in highlevel talents. At the same time, through the reform to “streamline administration, delegate power, strengthen regulation and improve services,” the state provides policy support and resource guarantee, and encourages universities to explore independently the employment system reform and job classification reform. Under the influence of market concepts such as performance and competition, rules such as contract employment, “either promotion or departure” and employment period assessment are widely used. Through academic committees at all levels in the universities and peer review system, academic logic continues to play its role. In the future, universities in China should balance performance competition and teachers’ occupational safety, giving equal attention to such factors as competition and guarantee, efficiency and fairness, and reform teachers’ personnel system with academic logic as the leading factor and under benign competition of other institutional logics.

参考文献 31

  • [ 1 ] 罗燕,叶赋桂.中国大学制度变革:新制度主义社会学分析——以2003年北大教师聘任和职务晋升制度改革为案例\[J\].复旦教育论坛,2005(6):46-50.
  • [ 2 ] 缪榕楠.大学教师任用制度研究\[D\].南京:南京师范大学,2007.
  • [ 3 ] 肖兴安.中囯高校人事制度变迁研究——历史制度主义的视角\[D\].武汉:华中科技大学,2012.
  • [ 4 ] 杨毅.新中国高校教师聘任制度变迁研究\[D\].重庆:西南大学,2013.
  • [ 5 ] 胡海青.中国大学教师聘任制改革的回顾与展望——基于理性选择制度主义分析\[J\]. 现代大学教育, 2010(3): 99-106.
  • [ 6 ] 李培利,刘凤良,宋东霞.高校教师长聘教职授予评价制度探析\[J\]. 中国人民大学教育学刊, 2016(1):111-118.
  • [ 7 ] Rubin B. A., Alford R. R. , Friedland R.. Powers of Theory: Capitalism, the State and Democracy\[J\]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1987, 32(2):318.
  • [ 8 ] Friedland R., Alford R. R.. Bringing Society Back in: Symbols, Practices, and Institutional Contradictions\[A\].Walter W. Powell, Paul J. DiMaggio. The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis\[C\]. Chicago: University of Chicago Press,1991: 233-258.
  • [ 9 ] Thornton P. H., Ocasio W.. Institutional Logics and the Historical Contingency of Power in Organizations: Executive Succession in the Higher Education Publishing Industry, 1958-1990\[J\]. American Journal of Sociology, 1999, 105(3):801-843.
  • [ 10 ] Kitchener M.. Mobilizing the Logic of Managerialism in Professional Fields: The Case of Academic Health Centre Mergers\[J\]. Organization Studies, 2002, 23(3):391-420.
  • [ 11 ] Thornton P. H., Ocasio W., Lounsbury M.. The Institutional Logics Perspective: A New Approach to Culture, Structure, and Process\[M\].Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.
  • [ 12 ] Evetts J.. New Professionalism and New Public Management: Changes, Continuities and Consequences\[J\]. Comparative sociology, 2009, 8(2): 247-266.
  • [ 13 ] \[英\]亨利·梅因著.古代法\[M\]. 沈景一,译. 北京:商务印书馆,1996.
  • [ 14 ] 任学丽.从身份到契约还是从契约到身份?——单位制度变迁视阈下的中国社会发展\[J\].社会主义研究,2011(6):92-95.
  • [ 15 ] 中共中央关于教育体制改革的决定\[J\].中华人民共和国国务院公报,1985(15):467-477.
  • [ 16 ] 中华人民共和国教师法\[EB/OL\].(1993-10-31)\[2022-01-25\]. http://www.moe.gov.cn/jyb_sjzl/sjzl_zcfg/zcfg_jyfl/tnull_1314.html.
  • [ 17 ] 《中国教育年鉴》编辑部.中国教育年鉴(1999)\[M\]. 北京:人民教育出版社,1999.
  • [ 18 ] 牛风蕊.我国高校教师职称制度的结构与历史变迁——基于历史制度主义的分析\[J\].中国高教研究,2012(10):71-74.
  • [ 19 ] 关于印发《关于加快推进事业单位人事制度改革的意见》的通知\[EB/OL\].(2000-07-21)\[2022-01-25\]. http://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2000/content_60418.htm.
  • [ 20 ] 许心,蒋凯.高校教师视角下的人文社会科学国际发表及其激励制度\[J\]. 高等教育研究, 2018,39(1): 43-55.
  • [ 21 ] 杨河清,陈怡安.海外高层次人才引进政策实施效果评价——以中央“千人计划”为例\[J\]. 科技进步与对策, 2013,30(16):107-112.
  • [ 22 ] 郭书剑.制度化精英主义与中国大学学术精英的生成\[J\].高等教育研究,2020,41(3):77-85.
  • [ 23 ] 陈先哲.学术锦标赛制: 中国学术增长的动力机制与激励逻辑\[J\].高等教育研究,2017,38(9): 30-36.
  • [ 24 ] 陈先哲.捆绑灵魂的卓越:学术锦标赛制下大学青年教师的学术发展\[J\].教育发展研究,2014(11):12-16.
  • [ 25 ] 阎光才.学术共同体内外的权力博弈与同行评议制度\[J\].北京大学教育评论,2009(1):124-138+191-192.
  • [ 26 ] 高等学校教师职务试行条例\[EB/OL\].(1986-12-31)\[2022-01-25\].http://www.moe.gov.cn/s78/A04/s7051/201001/t20100129_180698.html.
  • [ 27 ] 关于印发高等学校、义务教育学校、中等职业学校等教育事业单位岗位设置管理的三个指导意见的通知\[EB/OL\].(2007-05-07)\[2022-01-25\].http://www.mohrss.gov.cn/rydwrsgls/SYDWRSGLSzhengcewenjian/200705/t20070507_83800.html.
  • [ 28 ] 中共中央办公厅 国务院办公厅印发《关于分类推进人才评价机制改革的指导意见》\[EB/OL\].(2018-02-26)\[2022-01-25\]. http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/2018-02/26/content_5268965.htm.
  • [ 29 ] 教育部等六部门关于加强新时代高校教师队伍建设改革的指导意见\[EB/OL\].(2020-12-24)\[2022-01-25\].http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2021-01/27/content_5583070.htm.
  • [ 30 ] 晋兴雨,张英姿,于丽英.高校教师聘用制:政策演进与退出机制构建——基于A大学改革实践的分析\[J\].教育发展研究,2020,40(3):51-59.
  • [ 31 ] 王思懿,赵文华.多重制度逻辑博弈下的美国终身教职制度变迁\[J\]. 教育发展研究,2018 (1):76-84.