检索
在线阅读 --哲学社会科学版 1999年4期《求同与辨异——本世纪中国历史学一瞥》
求同与辨异——本世纪中国历史学一瞥--[在线阅读]
邢铁
河北师范大学历史系, 河北石家庄 050091
起止页码: 57--61,84页
DOI:
摘要
本世纪初史学大师们的研究是为学术而学术的学院式研究。从20年代后期开始,史学研究与当时的政治需要结合了起来,并由此形成了强调中国与世界其他民族历史的同一性或特殊性两种对立的思维方式。解放后过分强调同一性,近年来又突出特殊性,一直在“求同”与“辨异”的怪圈中摇摆,真正解决的学术问题并不多。我们这代人应当走出这个怪圈,回过头去续接一下本世纪初史学大师们的路子,静下心来认真研究和解决一些具体的学术问题。

The identity and the particularity——A stuay on Chinese historiography in the 20th Century
XING Tie
History Department, Hebei Narmal University, Shijiazhuang 050091, China
Abstract:
At the beginning of this century,the great masters of historical science did academic research in the way of academy for academy's sake.Since the latter half of the 1920's,historical research has been combined with the political needs of the time,and there appeared two contradictory thinking ways of thinking,——one laid emphasis upon identity between the history of China and its counterparts in the world,the other upon particularity.After 1949 identity gained too much emphasis.Recently,however,particularity has been paid more attention.Since neither is impartial,Only few academic problems have been solved.We should walk out of the strange circle of swinging from seeking common ground to distinguishing differences,resume the way in which the great masters were doing research work at the begenning of the century so that we will be able to solve some academic problems.

收稿日期: 1999-5-18
基金项目:

参考文献: