检索
在线阅读 --哲学社会科学版 2014年5期《论资政院激进特征的政治生态影响——以“弹劾军机大臣案”为中心》
论资政院激进特征的政治生态影响——以“弹劾军机大臣案”为中心--[在线阅读]
左攀, 唐仁郭
广西师范大学 历史文化与旅游学院, 广西 桂林 541001
起止页码: 98--103页
DOI: 10.13763/j.cnki.jhebnu.psse.2014.05.015
摘要
在1910年的资政院第一次常年会上,激进的议员两次弹劾军机大臣,其言论、行为、心态处处引领激进思潮。弹劾案是议院内外激进势力相互激荡的结果,也与载沣和军机大臣无视权力结构的巨大变化,依旧延续传统的政治思维和行事方式密切相关,更是宪政制度顶层设计的内在矛盾的具体体现。议员们的胆识和勇气固然可嘉,但他们的激进行为非但没能加快立宪步伐,反而严重破坏了政治生态,这种初衷与结果的背道而驰、程序与目的的错误取舍促使我们对政治激进主义深刻反思。历史的教训告戒我们:改革必须步步为营,率先营造绿色政治生态是政治转型成功的先决条件。

The radicalism of the cabinet in relation to the political and ecological impacts
ZUO Pan, TANG Ren-guo
School of History and Tourism, Guangxi Normal University, Guilin, Guangxi 541001, China
Abstract:
In 1910, at the first annual cabinet conference, radical senates twice attempt to impeach the military minister. The impeachment is the result of interactions between radical forces inside and outside the cabinet. This is also due to the fact that Zai Feng and the military minister keep ignoring the significant changes in the power structure, and that it even reflects inherent contradictions of the constitutional legislators, who are courageous, but whose aggressive behaviors only seriously damage the political ecology. The lesson is that reforms cannot be implemented radically, and the first step is to create a proper political environment as a prerequisite for a successful political transition.

收稿日期: 2014-6-11
基金项目: 国家社会科学基金西部项目(项目编号:12XZS025)

参考文献:
[1]左攀,张淼.弹劾军机大臣案述论[J].郧阳师范高等专科学校学报,2012(2).
[2]彭文贤.行政生态学[M].台北:三民书局,1988.
[3]资政院请旨裁夺公债案原奏[N].申报,1910-12-04.
[4]清实录(附)宣统政纪[M].北京:中华书局,1987.
[5]李启成点校.资政院议场会议速记录[M].上海:上海三联书店,2011.
[6]资政院奏参军机大臣责任不明难资辅弼折[N].国风报,1910-12-22.
[7]沥陈军机大臣失职不胜辅弼之任事[Z].清史编纂委员会数字资料库,档案号:04-01-01-1107-035.
[8]汪荣宝.汪荣宝日记[M].天津:天津古籍出版社,1987.
[9]Wittfogel K A. Oriental despotism: A comparative study of total power [M]. New York: Vintage books, 1981.
[10]寡廉鲜耻之军机[N].民立报,1910-12-15.
[11]专电[N].国民公报,1910-12-26.
[12]送议员[N].北京日报,1911-01-05.
[13]China in Revolution: The First Phase, 1900-1913[M]. Yale University Press, 1968.
[14]资政院第一次常年会议事录[M].北京:铅印单行本,1910.
[15]陶湘.齐东野语[M].陈旭麓.辛亥革命前后.上海: 上海人民出版社,1979.
[16]梁启超.梁启超全集[M].北京:北京出版社,1999.
[17]要闻[N].大公报,1910-11-25.
[18]辛亥革命回忆录(六)[M] .北京:中华书局,1963.
[19]萧一山.清代通史(五)[M].北京:中华书局,1985.
[20]戴逸,李文海.清通鉴[M].太原:山西人民出版社,1999.
[21]范忠信等编.近代中国宪政历程:史料荟萃[M].北京:中国政法大学出版社,2006.
[22]清末筹备立宪档案史料(上)[M].北京:中华书局,1978.
[23]萧功秦.危机中的变革:清末现代化进程中的激进与保守[M].上海:上海三联书店,1999.
[24]论军机处与资政院[N].北京日报,1910-11-14.
[25]社论[N].申报,1910-10-30.
[26]Ward R E. Political modernization and political culture in Japan[J]. World Politics, 1963.